Kaiser Permanente study tests new way to reduce ‘vaccine hesitancy’

Parent volunteers who value immunization show promise as advocates to help protect communities against contagious diseases

SEATTLE, April 11, 2017 — Results are promising for a new approach to reducing “vaccine hesitancy,” which happens when parents’ concerns about vaccine safety lead them to delay or skip their children’s immunizations, according to a Kaiser Permanente study published today in Health Promotion Practice: The Immunity Community: A Community Engagement Strategy for Reducing Vaccine Hesitancy.

The approach, called the Immunity Community, mobilizes parents who value vaccination to be advocates and to have positive conversations with other parents at their kids’ childcare centers, preschools and schools — in person and through social media.

Parents took a survey before and after the three-year intervention in two communities in Washington state. The surveys showed significant improvements in vaccine-related attitudes:

• Parents concerned about others not vaccinating their children rose from 81 percent to 89 percent.
• Those who called themselves “vaccine hesitant” fell from 23 percent to 14 percent.
• Fewer parents thought children receive vaccines at too young an age.
• More parents were confident that vaccinating their children is a good decision.
• More parents knew the vaccination rates at their children’s childcare or school.

“Our evaluation found that the Immunity Community program was successful at empowering parents to communicate positive messages about vaccines in a way that was not confrontational,” said study principal investigator Clarissa Hsu, PhD, of Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute’s Center for Community Health and Evaluation.

“Strong negative rhetoric about vaccines can circulate widely on social media. And some parents feel hesitant about early childhood vaccines and may delay or refuse some or all vaccines, which may put others in their community at risk,” Hsu said. “This project was designed to counterbalance prevalent anti-vaccine messages that do not reflect the fact that most (at least four in five) people vaccinate their kids and are supportive of vaccines.”

Why community immunity matters

Addressing vaccine hesitancy among parents is important because vaccines work best when a high proportion of people in a community are immunized against a contagious disease, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. This “community immunity” helps to protect everyone—including those who can’t receive vaccines, such as immunocompromised individuals.

Evidence from earlier studies indicates that parents who interact with other parents in a social network generally support vaccination if their peers do, and that they find the opinions of their peers trustworthy. That’s why Vax Northwest developed the Immunity Community. Vax Northwest is a unique public-private partnership in Washington state, including Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute, the Group Health Foundation, WithinReach, Seattle Children’s Hospital, BestStart Washington and the Washington State Department of Health.

“The Immunity Community program is innovative,” said study author Jennie Schoeppe, MPH, MS, of Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute’s Center for Community Health and Evaluation. “We are unaware of any other intervention that has used volunteer parent advocates to effect change in their communities.”

The study did have several limitations, including that it had no control group. Instead, information from parents was compared before and after the intervention. Some other factors may have supported increased vaccination during the 2011–2014 intervention period, including outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease and changes in state laws around school exemption policies.

Immunity Community changed policy

Not all participating sites are required to report their immunization rates to the Washington Department of Health. But the Immunity Community worked with the Organization of Parent Education Programs to improve the processes for tracking immunization rates and disease outbreaks for the children who attend cooperative preschools across the state of Washington. This policy change could affect thousands of families, according to Schoeppe.

This study is part of broader efforts by Kaiser Permanente and the Group Health Foundation to promote immunization as the most effective way to protect children from many infectious diseases, including ones that can cause serious disease and even death. The Group Health Foundation’s Childhood Immunization Initiative seeks to promote immunization and also funded the first randomized trial to test an intervention aimed at decreasing hesitancy about early childhood vaccines by working directly with doctors. Pediatricspublished those results in 2015.

In addition to Schoeppe and Hsu, the other study authors are Allen Cheadle, PhD, Creagh Miller, MPH, and Juno Matthys, of KPWHRI’s Center for Community Health and Evaluation; and Todd Faubion, PhD, and Mackenzie Melton, MPH, of WithinReach.

The Group Health Foundation supported this study. 

About Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute

Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute (KPWHRI) improves the health and health care of Kaiser Permanente members and the public. The institute has conducted nonproprietary public-interest research on preventing, diagnosing, and treating major health problems since 1983. Government and private research grants provide our main funding. Follow KPWHRI research on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn, or subscribe to our free monthly newsletter. 

About Kaiser Permanente

Kaiser Permanente is committed to helping shape the future of health care. We are recognized as one of America’s leading health care providers and not-for-profit health plans. Founded in 1945, Kaiser Permanente has a mission to provide high-quality, affordable health care services and to improve the health of our members and the communities we serve. We currently serve more than 12.4 million members in eight states and the District of Columbia. Care for members and patients is focused on their total health and guided by their personal Permanente Medical Group physicians, specialists and team of caregivers. Our expert and caring medical teams are empowered and supported by industry-leading technology advances and tools for health promotion, disease prevention, state-of-the-art care delivery and world-class chronic disease management. Kaiser Permanente is dedicated to care innovations, clinical research, health education and the support of community health. For more information, go to: kp.org/share.